Steve Swerdlow and Hugh Williamson
Open Democracy 26 October 2017
Erkin Musaev, Tashkent, September 2017 Picture: Hugh Williamson
The most striking thing about Erkin Musaev is his optimism. With a pleasant smile and gentle manner, he
told us over dinner in Tashkent about his ideas for improving Uzbekistan, his homeland.
Uzbekistan is going through a reform shake-up under president Shavkat Mirziyoyev, who last year took
over the reins following the death of the authoritarian leader Islam Karimov. There have been some
important human rights changes, but severe patterns of abuse still exist.
Many people are excited about the changes but Musaev, 50, is an unlikely candidate to be one of them.
He was a senior official for Karimov’s administration for many years, and one of his representatives to
NATO. Yet in 2006 he found himself facing bogus espionage charges, and was thrown in jail, convicted
and sentence to 20 years in prison. Musaev was severely tortured, and his health suffered during his 11
years behind bars. But then, in August, he was released -- one of more than 10 former political prisoners
set free since Mirziyoyev assumed the presidency.
“Since my release I’ve written to president Mirziyoyev and offered to support what he is doing,” Musaev
told us, referring to the president’s efforts to respond to ordinary people’s problems through a new
network of local complaint centers across Uzbekistan.
Considering the horrors Musaev lived through in prison, his eagerness to look forward is both refreshing
and deeply impressive. A specialist in military technology, Musaev worked in the 1990s for the Defense
Ministry, at one point also joining a US-sponsored exchange program to study English in Texas. His
NATO posting from 1997 to 2001 took him to Brussels, where he heard for the first time of concerns
about Uzbekistan’s human rights record.
In 1999 he attended an EU-Uzbekistan meeting on human rights during which the EU representatives
raised concerns about torture in Uzbek prisons. In the coffee break he recalls complaining to one of the
European delegates: “There is no torture in Uzbekistan!”
He pauses in his story, the bitter irony clear to him -- that this government official who defended
Tashkent’s record would just a few years later himself suffer the torture he asserted did not exist.
Later, he went to work for the Tashkent office of the UN Development Program, working on border
management issues.
He was arrested at Tashkent airport on January 31, 2006 and later coerced to sign a confession that he
had spied for the US, the UK and UN. One theory is that Karimov was angry at Western governments’
critical reactions to the killing of hundreds of protesters by government security forces in the eastern
Uzbek city of Andijan in May 2005. As a UN employee, Musaev was an attractive target.
Musaev said the circumstances of his arrest and interrogation would be laughable, if they were not so
serious. The first reason border guards gave for arresting him was that they allegedly found a CD
containing state secrets in his luggage. “The CD was planted in my luggage” Musaev said, noting that the
guards were hardly subtle with their plan. “The CD was labelled clearly: ‘secret information, Ministry of
Defense.’”
After months of interrogation and harrowing torture at his captors’ hands, Musaev “made up a history”
of his alleged spy activities. Musaev explained that such a strategy was the only way to halt the torture.
“The café I said I frequented did not actually exist, nor did the information I allegedly handled.”
While he was in detention UN bodies repeatedly said they had gathered credible evidence that Musaev
was tortured in prison. But hearing about it from the man himself is chilling. Held in a cramped cell in the
basement of the SNB security services for six months, he was beaten repeatedly on his head, chest and
feet. He felt like there was also little oxygen to breathe properly. “Those torturers are still working there”
he said.
In a 2008 public letter written after a prison visit, his wife, Rayhon Musaeva, said he had been beaten so
badly his face was unrecognizable. He was deprived of sleep and water on occasion throughout his prison
time.
“Often they would prevent us from sleeping for no reason, coming into my cell at 5 a.m. and forcing me
to ‘take a jog’ in the prison compound in the freezing cold” he told us. “At times, they [prison guards]
doused me with freezing cold water and then let me freeze. On another occasion, I was placed into an
extremely cold, closed cell for 10 days straight.”
Musaev, an educated man who read books by Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn and Barack Obama while in jail,
helped other prisoners write letters to relatives or to lodge complaints. “My prison nickname was ‘the
writer,’” he said, estimating that he wrote 150 letters a year for himself and others. He admitted, however,
that most, if not all, probably did not reach their destinations.
He also wrote a book while in prison, with stories about his fellow prisoners. But guards confiscated and
destroyed the manuscript, suspicious because it was written in Russian, not Uzbek.
Even this story doesn’t disrupt his optimism. He is clearly determined to catch up with the outside world
and move on with life as quickly as he can. He is brimming with ideas of how to make prisons more
humane, noting some modest improvements under Mirziyoyev while stressing how unjust the overall
system remains.
And does he have an underlying secret of how he survived and remained positive? His reply:
“Solzhenitsyn says that we should fight for justice until the end. If we don’t get justice, then the
repression will repeat itself. That’s’ what I’m trying to do.”
Hugh Williamson is the Europe and Central Asia director at Human Rights Watch. Steve
Swerdlow is the Human Rights Watch researcher working on Uzbekistan. Human Rights Watch
issued a report on October 24, 2017 assessing progress on human rights in Uzbekistan after a
year under the country’s new president, Shavkat Miryziyoyev.